This photo breaks the rules because it is heavily asymmetrical. Although my dog almost lies on one of the key points in the rule of thirds, he still is a bit too off to the side. I think this composition still works because it conveys an affect of inferiority and submission that a dog might experience.
This photo breaks the rules because of the blank space in the middle of the composition. The items in the foreground are blurry and the candle in the background breaks the theme of straight vertical objects. I think those things add visual interest and an element of chaos among an otherwise very pristine image.
This last photo breaks the rules mainly because of how heavy each side of the composition is. There is a predominantly white area on one side and a predominantly dark area on the others; these conflict. To add to this, there is a lamp dividing the room in half. I think this photo still works because the division creates an element of dysfunction which adds to the affect of a messy room.